News

Changing the who, what and how in media

Media shapes dominant opinions and attitudes. What we think about a topic, and often about other people, is hugely influenced by the media we consume. Whether it is climate change, Brexit, IndyRef or immigration the way an issue is covered and which opinions inform media make (and sometimes breaks) the society we’re in.

One not-so-small example – the pervasive relationship of public opinion and media on just one topic (Brexit) has become the focus of numerous PhDs and academic articles dedicated to analysing the extent of the media’s influence on the outcome of the EU Referendum – on just one online journal database, my last search produced 1758 articles on the topic.

Given this importance and influence, we need focus on the cultures within media and the extent to which it is closed to new, diverse and challenging voices. There are a number of initiatives working on doing exactly this and shifting the status quo; Gender Equal Media Scotland lists a range of them, including Pass the Mic.

The Pass the Mic project is about the who, the what and the how within media.

The Who: This one is obvious. The project website now has over 130 women of colour experts across a range of sectors and lived experience. The point of this is for media to see the expertise they are missing and source quotes, interviews and input from new people who have historically been overlooked. It is crucially about the representation of women of colour and them being respected as experts in a wide range of areas, combatting the discriminatory myths that persist of what Black, Asian, Hispanic, Latina, Arab, or mixed-race women are or can be.

The What: The website of experts and the funded paid commissions for women of colour are beyond simply visibility for the sake of visibility, it is also about widening “what” is being talked or written about. Increasing the number of women of colour in media is being pursued with the hope that there is a more competent balance in what media approaches us to discuss; more factual conversations about racism or sexism, and balanced with women of colour being asked for their input beyond these particular experiences if their expertise are in other areas – whether that’s engineering or the environment.

The How: Perhaps the hardest to shift, but the most necessary, is how the end product of commentary is produced. In the content itself, too often we read or watch debates which are given false equivalence; climate change deniers perceived to be on par with climate change scientists or increasingly often; the experience of racism being countered in “debate” by a representative of the far-right. This aspect of commentary is what many women of colour have said time and again, puts them off taking part, despite their voices being so critical; because often their own wellbeing is put on the line by participating in these types of “debates”. Alongside this issue, the decisions made about “how” an article or media piece is put together can either help or hinder the involvement of women of colour, or can dispel or entrench stereotypes or discriminatory attitudes. A recent example of this was the disproportionate inclusion of South Asian and East Asian communities in images used in articles related to Covid-19 and in particular lockdown restrictions or the contravening of restrictions despite there being no evidence whatsoever that these communities were less likely to abide by lockdown rules. These choices made (consciously or not) harm the trust communities of colour have in media and reinforce negative attitudes towards them.

Pass the Mic is an ambitious project to challenge the representation of women of colour, but it is approaching it with pragmatism by both sourcing the expertise that media have not sourced themselves and challenging the cultures across multiple levels of Scottish media; we want to work both at the individual and system level – because we want to make a tangible difference. Get involved.  

Blog

The Importance of Diversity and Representation in Scottish Media

The importance of having diversity and representation in Scottish media cannot be understated. I have long called for better representation that reflects the national portrait of this country and there are many others pioneering the movement for representation here at Pass the Mic founded by Talat Yaqoob.  Coming together to present opportunities for the plethora of talent from diverse backgrounds is a welcomed approach to bridging the gaps in diversity that we often see within the media landscape. There are so many talented women and men that come from diverse backgrounds that can contribute their skills and talents to a wealth of content within the media but often face challenges in doing so. 

I was recently deemed the first hijab-wearing TV reporter in Scotland when I did my first TV report for STV News at Six. This was a significant moment for me not because of my identity but because I finally felt that I had overcome the glass ceiling that I felt I had been under for so long. Since the report aired and I highlighted my experiences of facing challenges within my career of being judged for being a visibly Muslim woman, I was inundated with messages. People from all over the industry in the UK and around the world contacted with their own experiences of facing discrimination and seeking advice on how to break the barriers and overcome potential problems that may occur when seeking to progress within the media.

Since speaking to those who have been in contact, I am now collaborating with others within the media industry to help support those who are facing challenges of discrimination and also working to call for better representation and diversity in the UK media through a campaign I started on change.org. One of the main reasons why representation and diversity is so important is due to the fact that we all need to be reflected on screen. I can resonate with the saying that ‘if you can’t see it you can’t be it’. The media often shapes our portrayals of the world and gives an insight into the society at large. If we are unable to see all types of people on our screens what message does that give out to viewers? It shows that certain spaces or industries are for some people and not for others and this is completely unacceptable. No one should ever have to feel that achieving their goals within the media is out of reach due to their race, faith, age, gender or any other factor.

I am working to support the facilitation of a dedicated complaints and support body that one can turn to if they do feel they are unable to progress because they have been discriminated against. In addition, I would like to pass on some tips on how I managed to overcome the hurdles of transitioning from online and print journalism into broadcast with the hope that it can be of some use to those who read this post.

Tips to Succeed within the Media Industry

Perseverance

There are many times when you may feel like giving up or are tired of facing rejection after rejection. I have been there myself and it is normal to feel that way . However, I have realised that in this industry if you really want to succeed perseverance is key. I wouldn’t have been able to achieve anything if I had not kept working hard and persevering.

Hone your skills

Knowledge is power and the more skills you acquire the better. I always strive to improve myself and learn new skills or perfect existing ones. This can help you if you want to transition to a certain area of the media and open up more opportunities.

Network

I have found networking to be really beneficial in building new working relationships, collaborating on projects and even making new friends with fellow journalists. I think it is a great way of building up a support system and can be especially beneficial if you are a freelancer like myself who often works alone in comparison to an organisation.

Look after your wellbeing

Mental health is everything and when you may feel low or have faced any issues  within the media industry that has impacted you, it is important to talk to someone that you trust. I have found it helpful speaking to family members whenever I faced set backs or rejections related to my identity.

And finally…

Keep on going!

Sign the petition for better representation and diversity and share the hashtag #betterrepresentation here – https://www.change.org/p/media-organisations-a-campaign-for-better-representation-and-diversity-in-uk-media

News

Exciting News! We’ve been funded!

The Pass the Mic project has successfully secured funding from the Joseph Rowentree Charitable Trust.

The year long funding will support a number of activities to provide development opportunities for women of colour in Scotland who are interested in being more involved as commentators in Scotland’s media, but crucially, will focus on challenging the status quo in Scotland’s newspapers, TV news and radio. Women of colour may be in the minority across Scotland’s population, but even a proportionate number of this minority are not represented in media, our expertise are overlooked. Too often we are talked about, rather than talked to, or given the platform to talk for ourselves.

As a consequence, damaging tropes about women of colour are reinforced by media, on many occassions issues related to sexism and racism overlook our existence completely and instead make assumptions about our experiences or minimise our realities. This must change.

This funding will kick off on the 1st of September and will support Pass the Mic to grow. We will do this through:

  • Media monitoring research – we will be analyising media across all platform to investigate who is doing the talking and writing and what issues are being covered. This will help us hold media to account on the invisibility of the issues which impact women of colour’s lives and on the extent of the under-representation of women of colour expert.
  • Research on what women of colour want to see change in the media, what development opportunities they are looking for and how inclusive and accountable cultures can be created across media.
  • We will be delivering development sessions (likely to be online) which are informed by what women of colour experts want and will support the development of media contacts and networks by hosting introductions and interviews with editors and reporters.
  • The funding will include paid commissions for women of colour with media partners – the topics will be set by women of colour on their area of expertise and/or lived experience.

We are really excited about the next year, and want to make sure the delivery of this project is well informed and leaves a real legacy for change. If you have ideas or want to be more involed in it – drop us a line!